Bake Off: The American Baking Competition Cookbook

Pie Recipes

Old Fashioned Pie Recipes include cream pies, no bake pies,  cobbler, and a Flaky Pie Crust to delight your family.

The world loves pies. Folks have been baking them for hundreds of years. Our pilgrims loved them so much they brought their favorite recipes, which consisted mostly of the mincemeat type, to America. Soon they discovered how to make fruit, vegetable, custard and cream pies, using foods the American Indians taught them to eat.

Popular magazines were featuring holiday pie recipes in 1935. Here you will find an Old-Fashioned Pumpkin Pie that was featured in the Good-Housekeeping magazine, November issue, in 1937. We have enjoyed this pumpkin pie for many years on Thanksgiving day.



Whip up a favorite traditional pie in our delicious homemade Flaky Pie Crust from scratch and make any meal, a special occasion.


Angel Pie Recipe

Made with fruit cocktail, oranges and whipped cream in a Honey Graham cracker crust. Taste like a Dreamsicle Pie. Delicious!


Blueberry Pie

Made with frozen blueberries, enhanced with vanilla extract, and cooked in an old fashioned flaky pie crust. A winner!

Cherry Cobbler
A juicy, delicious Old Fashioned Cherry Cobbler made easy with canned Sour Red Cherries, self-rising flour, and butter.

Chocolate Pudding Pie
Will delight your family with it's alluring fragrance and silky texture. Make it a pudding or make it a pie. Both ways are shown.

Coconut Cream Pie
Savory and creamy. Cook the Old Fashioned Way on the stove top or microwave the quick and easy way. Both are equally delicious!

Cream Cheese Pie
Layered with chocolate in a butter and pecan crust. Topped with whipped cream. Luscious pie will become an often requested dessert!.

Easy Apple Pie
An old fashioned recipe that is not sweet not too spicy baked in a deep dish flaky pie crust and toped with a delicious glaze of cream and sugar.


Egg Custard
An elegant Old Fashioned Recipe made with milk, eggs, sugar and flavorings.

Flaky Pie Crust
This perfect pie crust recipe from scratch is tender,tasty AND flaky. It freezes well. Saves you money, too!

Key Lime Pie
Tart filling in a honey graham cracker crust. Topped with meringue and coconut and baked long enough to toast. Yummy!

Lemon Pie
Made with freshly squeezed lemon juice, lemon cookie crust, and topped with whipped cream. Microwave. Instructions to convert to a Lemon Meringue Pie.

Lime Yogurt Pie
Made with lime yogurt and cream cheese in a honey graham cracker crust. Quick and Easy!

Peanut Butter Pie
Made with cream cheese, whipped cream, roasted peanuts and topped with Homemade Chocolate Sauce. Sumptuous!

Peach Cobbler
Adapted from Mama's old recipe containing canned peaches. Sprinkled with granulated sugar for a delicious crunchy crust.

Pear Cobbler With Apples
Made with raisins and spices topped with a glazed crust of self-rising flour, brown sugar, butter and nuts.

Pumpkin Pie
Dates back to 1937. Truly an old-fashioned taste. Not too sweet, not too spicy. Sure to become your family favorite!

Quiche Recipe
Lamplighter Restaurant Quiche Recipe with tangy Blue Cheese, parsley, and chives. Delicious old fashion recipe.


Yogurt Pie
This pie recipe is made with cream cheese in a vanilla wafer crust topped with whipped cream and fresh strawberries. Irresistible!


Other Pie Recipes

The following recipes are listed under our puddings. However, they can be made into pies. Cook the fillings a few minutes longer.


Banana Split Pie

Butterscotch Pudding



Return from Pie Recipes to Old Fashioned Recipes


Custom Search



Follow Me on Pinterest

New Recipes

Menu Of The Month

Kitchen Tips & More

Subscribe to my e-zine

It's FREE!

Enter Your E-mail Address
Enter Your First Name (optional)
Then

Don't worry — your e-mail address is totally secure.
I promise to use it only to send you Old Fashioned Recipes E-zine.