Banana Split Pie Recipe
Submitted by LISA - North Carolina

Banana Split Pit

My aunt Ella Mae Jacobs had a God given gift for cooking. She could cook anything from scratch without recipes. Experience is the best teacher, but she had a palate to go with all that experience.

She made the most delicious homemade cakes I have ever eaten. She would taste the batter as she went along, adding a little of this or that until it tasted perfect.

I think one of her key secrets was that she always used real butter in her baked goodies.

She made the best fried chicken I have ever tasted, using the simple old-fashioned cast iron skillet method.

Now that I am older, I regret not spending more time with her in the kitchen.

But I would probably weigh 300 pounds if could cook like her!

The following recipe is my own, and more my speed because it's quick, simple, and inexpensive.

It tastes great and you won't have hardly any dishes to wash when it's done!

This tastes like an ice cream banana split pie recipe to me.

Basically, you will be making a banana pudding but using chocolate pudding instead of vanilla, with some chopped pecans on top to give it that banana split appeal.

Banana Split Pie Recipe

  •  1/2 of a box of vanilla wafers
  • 1 (5.9 oz.) box of Jello instant chocolate pudding
  • 2 large ripe bananas, sliced
  • 2 1/2 cups of cold milk
  • 1/2 - 3/4 of an 8 oz. tub of Frozen Whipped topping. (I prefer the red label Cool Whip because it is made with milk instead of water, so it tastes better.)
  • 1/4 cup of chopped pecans
  • Maraschino Cherries

I use a 2 quart storage type plastic container to make this, because that is what I have on hand and it saves space in the fridge.

But you can use what ever type of casserole dish you have that will hold 2 quarts.

In separate bowl, mix instant pudding with milk according to directions on box. (*Directions for pie filling, using 2 1/2 cups of cold milk.

This will give a delicious chocolate favor and keep wafers from becoming soggy.)

Set aside.

In dish, start with a layer of vanilla wafers on bottom, then top each one with a slice of banana.

I sliced my bananas to about 1/3 - 1/2 of an inch thick.

Then pour 1/2 of the prepared pudding over top of the first layer of wafers and bananas.

Then repeat with a second layer.

If you are using a deep dish like I do, add some wafers and banana slices around the sides of the dish.

You want to use a slice of banana for each wafer, with the exception that you may want to top the second layer of bananas with a 3rd and final layer of wafers.

I do mine that way, and it came out just right.

Then pour remaining pudding over top, spreading evenly.

At this point, because you are using instant pudding that is already cold, you can go ahead and put on your whipped topping if you wish.

The whipped cream layer should be about 1/2 as thick as the finished pudding, for best taste.

Sprinkle chopped pecans over top of whipped cream.

If preferred, drizzle some Homemade Chocolate Sauce over top.

Garnish with Maraschino Cherries, as desired.

Refrigerate several hours or over night.

Banana Split made with Chocolate pudding.

If you are using the type of whipped topping that comes in the can, do not add it until ready to serve the pudding.

Canned Whipped will begin to melt down and become runny within minutes.  (I found that out the hard way! Oops!)

Don't forget to add the pecans.

Like this? You may also enjoy my Cream Cheese Pie

Like this? You may also enjoy my
Cream Cheese Pie

Return to Old Fashioned Pudding Recipes

Return from Banana Split Pie Recipe to Old Fashioned Recipes

Like this page? Please share with your family and friends so those you care about can enjoy Old Fashioned Recipes again.

To share on Twitter and Facebook tap on button.

What's New

  1. Spaghetti Recipe

    Sep 19, 20 07:42 PM

    Spaghetti Recipe made with ground beef chuck, an old fashioned pasta sauce, and a sour cream topping for a restaurant quality meal.

    Read More

  2. Boston Cream Pie Recipe

    Aug 14, 20 03:17 PM

    Old fashioned Recipe, Boston Cream Pie has a Vanilla Custard Filling and is topped with a Homemade Hot Fudge Sauce. Serve hot or cold.

    Read More